Author Archives: Michael Froomkin

Some Election!

First Draft – Deomocrazy reports that a full five — count them, five! — days before the election, the Iraqi voters get to know who the candidates are! Such great democracy.

In a few days, they'll even get to know where some of the polling places are! (I am not making this up—many voters, except of course for those in the three provinces where we aren't bothering with elections at all, will be eligible to learn where the polling places are on election day.)

And no cars, just in case you wanted a ride to the polls.

And we closed down a major opposition newspaper months ago. And are enforcing Saddam's anti-union laws.

And… oh, what's the point?

Posted in Iraq | 5 Comments

It Was 60 Years Ago Today…

C.E. Petit, he of the luridly designed but very interesting “Scrivener's Error”, notes an important and under-reported anniversary.

Posted in Blogs | Comments Off on It Was 60 Years Ago Today…

Blogware Obsolescence Creeps Up

Six Apart released a patch to MT 2.661 and 3.x that fixes a hole which would allow evildoers to send email to third parties. Unfortunately, the patch is not promised to be compatible with lower versions, such as 2.64 which is what I'm running. I purposefully didn't upgrade to 2.66x because I didn't like some of the new improved features. And I didn't go to 3.x because some of my favorite plugins won't work there and it would require some redesign of the site, which would take time.

But it's increasingly clear that I'm reaching the end of the line. Sooner or later I have to either go to 3.x, which is hard, or to WordPress, which will be a very very hard conversion, especially for the archived posts.

I have other things to do.

Meanwhile, I've loaded up the patch despite the lack of warranty. Please drop me a note if something seems weirder than usual.

Posted in Discourse.net | 5 Comments

The Evidence of Systematic Widespread Torture Is Growing: More Tales of Abuses In Iraq

Neil Lewis reports that A.C.L.U. Presents Accusations of Serious Abuse of Iraqi Civilians. But this isn't about the Abu Ghraib:

The new accusations generally concern the behavior of American Special Forces, as opposed to prison guards or interrogators, who have been accused at Abu Ghraib.

Rather, it's yet another sign of a pattern and practice.

The American Civil Liberties Union released documents on Monday describing complaints of serious abuse of Iraqi civilians, including reports of electric shocks and forced sodomy, and accused the military of not thoroughly investigating the cases.

The documents list dozens of allegations of abuse at American detention centers – the use of cigarettes to burn prisoners, aggressive dogs, electric shocks, sexual humiliation and beatings – that began at about the same time such acts were occurring at Abu Ghraib prison.

But it is not always clear whether every case described is a new incident.

Based only on the public evidence to date, how much is the ordinary carnage and inhumanity of war, and how much is something that trickled down from above, may be hard to say in a way that would satisfy the 'beyond a reasonable doubt' standard. But there seems to be the makings of at the very least a very strong case that is more than circumstantial. If a prosecutor were to tackle this with the aggressiveness with which we pursue Mafia cases, I think we'd see something. But there's no sign yet of any desire to go after general officers, or even mid-level officers, much less ranking civilians.

Posted in Iraq Atrocities | 2 Comments

A Koufax Nomination (re: Torture Memos) I Might Actually Have a Chance At

In my third (wow!) Koufax nomination, Discourse.net is nominated for The Koufax Awards: Best Series for my item on the Bybee Torture Memo.

This isn't like my other nominations, where although I'm delighted to be in their company, I think other people so clearly deserve to win that it would be a travesty to vote for me. I could cope with this one.

So, please, if you liked the series, go vote — once.

Oddly, even though the nomination is for a series, it doesn't mention the several related items I wrote, including:

Update: The nice people at Wampum have included the whole list now.

Posted in Discourse.net | 6 Comments

Automated Communal Sharing of (Online) Experiences

Continuing on the theme of not-immediately-obvious ways in which the net moves information, have a look at Terra Nova: Automated Expertise Management. This tells the tale of Thottbot.com,

At first glance, Thottbot looks like a normal third-party MMORPG information site. Try searching for “Fiery Enchantments” – a lvl 42 quest in the game. Thottbot has the details of the quest stored. But imagine I just picked up this quest and I don't know where these “dragon whelps” are that drop the “black drake's heart”. If I follow the “black drake heart” link, Thottbot shows me all the mobs that drop it, their level ranges, and most importantly where to find them. Click on the “map” link next to the lvl 41 Scalding Whelp. Thottbot dynamically generates a map of the zone where these mobs are found and their spawn range. All items, quests, mobs and maps are cross-referenced in Thottbot.

Now, you might think that Thottbot has this information because of constant submissions from good-hearted players (which is how other sites do it), but that's not what's happening. There is a free custom GUI called Cosmos which allows customized toolbars as well as mods that add functionality. Of interest to us here is that Cosmos also sends information (optional) to the Thottbot database from every player who uses it. Every mob, item, quest and player character that is encountered has their stats and location tracked and sent to Thottbot automatically.

In other words, the expertise of individual players is automatically tracked, stored and shared by the system. More importantly, the aggregation of their expertise allows the discovery of what would otherwise be hard to know – the spawning ranges of mobs, the drop rates of rare and uncommon items, and so on.

It's not that hard to imagine how this gets generalized to other types of online activities within structured settings…maybe google searches, ebay bidding strategies, or comparative shopping. It's somewhat harder to see how this helps me outside structured action/query-response environments. But if it did…

Posted in Internet | 1 Comment