Author Archives: Michael Froomkin

Cheap Motherboards Can Be Just as Good

Tom’s Hardware Guide — the Internet authority on computer hardware, compares a budget and premium motherboard. The result is surprising, even given they’re both made by the same well-regarded manufacturer:

The low-budget and the premium motherboard provide exactly the same performance when using comparable components.

The only difference that mattered is the feature set, but the $69 board had everything the average user would need, meaning that the $219 model makes no sense unless you are a serious overclocker, plan to use many hard drives, or have a special need for one of the other extra features.

Posted in Sufficiently Advanced Technology | 1 Comment

Robert Waldman Annotates the Iraqi Proto-Constitution

The first draft of history: Robert Waldman points out key clauses of the Iraqi proto-constitution.

Posted in Iraq | Comments Off on Robert Waldman Annotates the Iraqi Proto-Constitution

Rashomon, Jackboots Edition (Updated)

One view: Daily Kos: UTAH RAVERS TREATED LIKE TERRORISTS!

The other view: Rave Party: Utah County Sheriff’s Office shuts down Rave Party in Spanish Fork Canyon.

The accounts differ as to whether the ravers had all the permits they needed (you need a permit to have more than 250 people on private land way out in the middle of nowhere? So it seems…)

Note however, that there is little but very violent resistance that would justify the kind of force the police are alleged to have used.

Not having been there or knowing any of the participants personally, I am unwilling to rush to judgment as to which account more closely captures the truth, although I’ll say this much: if it proves to be true that the the cops were impounding cameras and trying to stop filming, I think it’s fair to suspect that they might have had something to hide.

And if the accounts of violence, or raiding-despite-a-permit-and-without-a-warrant prove true, then the Utah police are simply out of control — or worse, controlled by really bad and evil people.

Update: As is increasingly often the case, info central on this issue is the wikipedia entry. And what to make of this unsourced claim: “A source inside the Utah government reports that this action was undertaken out of fear that the Rave would be used to rally support for the protest against Bush’s upcoming Utah visit.” They couldn’t be that crazy. Could they?

Posted in Civil Liberties | 5 Comments

Independent Writing Opportunity

[Readers, forgive me, but this item is primarily directed at UM law students, although of course I welcome comments from all and sundry.]

Students sometimes ask me whether I would supervise them for an independent writing project. If it’s something I know about, I’m willing. And, in the rare case it’s something no one the faculty knows about or the more common case where people who know about it are already maxed out, I’m probably willing. You see, students don’t often want me as their supervisor: I’m pretty demanding. I see our goal as to write something publishable, not just another term paper.

If you are interested in writing a paper please turn in a two page memo (on paper or in the body — not an attachment — of an email) on your proposed paper topic, listing the issues you intend to address and (perhaps) your first guess as to what you will say about them. I need this memo no later than the end of the second week of classes. Based on this memo I will either approve the topic or propose modifications. We will meet from time to time, on a schedule we’ll set up and you are also welcome to contact me at any time with questions. I will expect you to turn in a rough draft at a date to be agreed (some time around midterm), and I will return the rough draft with comments as soon as I can, on a first-come, first-served basis. You will not be graded on your rough draft — the comments are entirely for your benefit with no strings attached. The final draft is due the last day of classes unless we agree otherwise. In addition to giving me a hard copy of your paper, please turn in a floppy disk containing the full project to my secretary, Rosalia Lliraldi, who sits near room 382 in the library.

In picking a topic — by far the hardest part of the project — I advise you to consult Eugene Volokh, Academic Legal Writing: Law Review Articles, Student Notes, Seminar Papers, and Getting on Law Review (2d ed.) [on reserve in the library] for a wealth of useful tips on picking a topic and writing the paper. I’ve also got a few idiosyncratic writing tips that I hold very dear.

Posted in U.Miami | Comments Off on Independent Writing Opportunity

President Shalala Podcasts

How many university presidents podcast? Well, ours does: President Shalala’s Top-Ten List for New Students.

Posted in U.Miami | Comments Off on President Shalala Podcasts

The Year Begins

One of the things about academic life is that it moves to its own rhythm. New Years day is an artifact of the common calendar and has fairly little meaning to me; (and Rosh ha Shona we barely notice). What’s more, as transatlantic flights tend to be cheaper on Dec. 31, we have slept through the stroke of midnight, jet lagged, for almost every one of the past ten years. I can’t remember the last time I went to a New Year’s Party, nor can I imagine how I’d get a sitter even if I were not jet lagged.

No, the real start of the year in this household is around now, when the kids go back to school, and when we have our first classes of the academic year.

My first Administrative Law class is 8am today (Monday). Last week I posted my assignments for both my classes. But if the past is a guide, fewer than half the students will admit having seen them. (Perhaps they’re afraid of being called on.)

Meanwhile, I get to enjoy the first fruits of one of the assignments I always use to start the semester. For my Internet Law class, I have asked every student to send me a paragraph about themselves with contact information plus whatever they’d like me to know about them, and paragraphs have started dribbling in. (In Administrative Law, we’ll do that in class some time around the end of the add-drop period as Administrative Law seems more subject to turnover.) Our students have interesting–and in some cases, rather harrowing–lives.

I have always had great trouble learning names by heart (any proper names, including case names), but I find it easy to remember facts; having facts about people helps me overcome my name-learning handicap, although not enough. But I’d ask for the paragraph even if I were good at names. Other than seminars, even my smaller classes tend to be around 30 people, and this year it looks as if they’ll be more in the 40-60 range. At that size, it’s difficult to get to know many students as people. In addition to being intrinsically interesting, the paragraphs give me a big jump start.

Posted in Law School | 1 Comment