The payroll tax has proved to be an effective way to redistribute a small amount of money from the rich to the poor and therefore we should seize every opportunity to undermine it; if this makes Social Security less solvent, all the better! (Summarizing “Our Enemy, the Payroll Tax”))
Recent Bluessky Posts- Yikes? April 10, 2026 Michael Froomkin
- Jotwell Legal Hist: Jedidiah Kroncke, The Forgotten Violence and Perpetual Tensions of American Labor History, JOTWELL (Apr 10, 2026) (re: María E. Montoya, A Workplace of Their Own: Rockefeller, Roche, and Labor's Battle Over Industrial Democracy (2026)), legalhist.jotwell.com/the-forgotte.... April 10, 2026 Jotwell
- I hear mathematicians screaming. April 9, 2026 Michael Froomkin
- Jotwell Property: Andrea Boyack, Fairer Housing in the Face of Frequent Floods, JOTWELL (April 9, 2026) (reviewing Jade A. Craig, Struggle Against the Water: Connecting Fair Housing Law and Climate Justice, 24 Nev. L.J. 737 (2024)), property.jotwell.com/fairer-housi.... April 9, 2026 Jotwell
- I'll be virtual. Immunocompromise, alas. April 8, 2026 Michael Froomkin
The payroll tax, which regressively taxes income flatly only up to a maximum income threshold, so that working people can pay to supplement other people’s retirement is a /what/ again? A redistribution from the rich to the poor? Where did you get that idea?
Of course you are right — but the nonsense I wrote is an accurate summary of Douthat’s (inane) argument.
FWIW I support the exact opposite of what Douthat wants: I’d like to take the cap off the payroll tax.
As Sadly No! put it recently: “‘Shorter’ concept created by Daniel Davies and perfected by Elton Beard. We are aware of all Internet traditions.™”