Evidence for the hypothesis that modern life in the USA is increasingly Dickensian: Big Retail Chains Dun Mere Suspects in Theft. Incredible. And right here in Florida…
Recent Bluessky Posts- Happy Bastille Day to those who celebrate it. Was always a special day in my house growing up. July 14, 2026 Michael Froomkin
- Jotwell Jurisprudence: Thomas Bustamante, Bentham on the Citizen’s Duty to Hold Political Authorities Accountable, JOTWELL (July 14, 2026), juris.jotwell.com/bentham-on-t.... 1/2 July 14, 2026 Jotwell
- Thought I might mention that Judge Kathleen Williams, author of this very fine opinion on Trump's attempt at collusive litigation to get both a slush fund from the Treasury and a free pass from IRS, storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.us..., is a graduate of the University of Miami School of Law. July 14, 2026 Michael Froomkin
- Jotwell Adlaw: Nicholas Parrillo, The Administrative Law of the Civil Service, JOTWELL (July 13, 2026) (reviewing Nicholas Bednar, Presidential Control of the Civil Service, 110 Minn. L. Rev. 2065 (2026)), adlaw.jotwell.com/the-administ.... July 13, 2026 Jotwell
- I demand they send me $100,000 forthwith. If they can demand stuff with no legal basis, why can't I? July 10, 2026 Michael Froomkin
When the law is a tool used by the wealthy to control and hurt the poor.
We as consumers have been been sliced up into tranches and sold off. Its really as simple as that.
Does this kind of predatory legal practice appear on the ethics exam? (I thought not).
As the article makes clear the Florida Bar Association has yet to take any of the complaints about predatory lawyering, including harassing telephone calls, seriously. Zealous advocacy is one thing, but this type of behavior goes beyond the norms sanctioned by the rules of professional conduct.
Down in the WSJ story we read that several of those who were wrongly accused and threatened later won suits against the retailers. Great, but what bugs me is that the settlements are secret. Big contradiction to the ideal of transparency, and it’s all over the place.
Well… I understand the concept of zealous representation, but this is pretty over the top. The FL Bar really needs to address this.
@ Joe— Good point!!
In the UK the handyman could sue Home Depot for slander by deed. The precedent is a case involving W.H.Smith. Accuse a person of theft and get it wrong and you stand to loose rather more than the $3000 being demanded by Home Despot.
I don’t see why the same principle should not apply here. I have no problem with the stores being able to sue rather than bring criminal charges. But they have to be accountable for errors.