October 19, 2008

Simple Logic

Pat Buchanan says Colin Powell endorsed Obama because he’s black (via Crooks and Liars).

Does this mean that Buchanan — and tens of thousands of other Irish-Americans, not to mention other hyphens — endorsed McCain because he’s white?


Posted by Michael : October 19, 2008 10:12 PM | Politics: US: 2008 Elections | TechnoLinks
Slashdot   Slashdot It!
Comments

Yes. Yes, they did. They surely didn't think he'd be a better President. So it must be his race that's the determining factor.

Posted by: jim at October 20, 2008 09:56 AM

Well, I endorsed Obama because I'm white and pro-America.

Posted by: BroD at October 20, 2008 09:21 PM

I think the correct answer to this is "so what?"

I'm against "tribal politics," and I'm tremendously anti-race-based affirmative action (but heavily in favor of class based AA, which would serve the same purpose). Nevertheless, I must admit that a *part* of my support for Obama is because he is (half) black. So what? I think that we, as a nation, would benefit from his unique experiences as a (half) black American.

No matter what your politics, if you can't admit that African Americans have gotten a raw deal on this continent, you must be wearing some pretty dark sunglasses. If a black man wants to support another black man because he is rooting for the home team, why is that a bad thing?

That all said, I don't recall Colin Powell backing Alan Keyes. I disagree that Powell would or did back Obama just on account of race. But, I think the right retort is "so freakin what"?


Posted by: Marc J. Randazza at October 23, 2008 11:07 AM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?




Comments must be previewed once before posting (this discourages automated posting).


Did you happen to see these?
Early Voting Takes Determination - Oct 23, 2008
Intrade Market Manipulation? - Oct 17, 2008
Most Effective Commercial of the Year? - Oct 17, 2008


Add Discourse.net to your RSS/RDF/XML reader: Full feed
Partial feed

Powered by Movable Type 2.64.


   out of