Text of Judge Leon’s Remarks in Guantanamo Habeas Case

Thanks to SCOTUSblog, we have Documents on Boumediene detainee ruling including a full transcript of the remarks by Judge Leon, that I mentioned previously (Judge Grants Writ of Habeas Corpus for 5 out of 6 Gantanamo Detainees)

Here's the key excerpt from the transcript, significantly reformatted for easier reading:

Now, I want to raise a note of caution to those who may be listening or to those who will read my ruling. This is a unique case. Few, if any others, will be factually like it. Few, if any others, will be factually like it. Nobody should be lulled into a false sense that all of the Government's cases will look like and be like this one. If there is any lesson that the parties and the Court have learned, these cases are unique and the habeas process must be flexible.

The practical effect of the Supreme Court's decision to superimpose the habeas process into the world of intelligence gathering is to create a virtually limitless complex of novel and difficult questions. As a result, the precedential value, if any, should be and is — should be and is limited to these cases.

One last point I would like to make.

The Court appreciates fully that the Government has a right to appeal its decision as to these five detainees whose petitions I have granted. I have a right, too, to appeal to the senior-most leadership at the Department of Justice, Department of Defense, and the CIA and other intelligence agencies. My appeal to them is to strongly urge them to take a hard look at the evidence, both presented and lacking, as to these five detainees. Seven years of waiting for our legal system to give them an answer to a question so important, in my judgment, is more than plenty.

The appellate process for these five detainees would, at a minimum, constitute another 18 months to two years of their lives. It seems to me that there comes a time when the desire to resolve novel, legal questions and decisions which are not binding on my colleagues pales in comparison to effecting a just result based on the state of the record.

Detainees' counsel will undoubtedly file an appeal with regard to my decision denying Mr. Bensayah's petition. That appeal will provide more than enough opportunity for both sides to challenge the novel, legal rulings that this Court has had to make.

I appeal to the senior leadership of those agencies to bring to an end this process as to these five detainees. We will stand in recess.

Strong stuff.

This entry was posted in Guantanamo. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Text of Judge Leon’s Remarks in Guantanamo Habeas Case

  1. Randon says:

    Strong stuff indeed. Definitely supports the Party’s view that appellate courts are unnecessary, or at least will be, once the Party has its own judges in place. For that matter, it also suggests the lack of any need for an executive branch, as a judicial branch run by the Party could do fine without any meddling.

    The Party of course supports the elimination of the “Chinese walls” between the branches. The President absolutely should be telling the Supreme Court how to decide cases, and since The Mighty O is a Constitutional Scholar with a Law Degree from Harvard we fully expect him to do so. The Supreme Court, once the Mighty O has appointed it, should directly advise Congress which bills to pass, and which the Mighty O should sign.

    This will of course prepare the populace for the removal of the antiquated 3 branches of government into a unified oneness. This one-branch system shall occur during the Pax Obama.

    Again, excellent work. It is important you impart upon your law students that the separation of powers is foolish and that Enlightened judges should tell the other branches how to do their jobs. Step by step we can destroy the mistake called the Constitution that restrains the Party from its full glory.

    All Hail the Mighty O!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.