What He Said, What I Did, What They Said

This is right: Hullabaloo: Gentleman’s Agreement. That’s the “what he said” part of this post.

Isn’t it odd that major corporations foster so much hatred on the air? It’s clear that Limbaugh and the Fox types are not joking. They are not even “joking”.

So it’s nice to see someone doing something to strike back. I suspect that Chris Matthews would not have been my top choice, or probably even one of my top three, for an advertiser boycott, but you start where you are. And where we are right now is An Open Letter to Chris Matthews.

So here’s what I did. I wrote emails to Intuit and to Toyota because I’m a long-time buyer of their products. And I also used the comment form on their web site. And I said that, much as I like their products, I wouldn’t buy again until they disassociate themselves from this filth. For Toyota it’s a car. For Intuit it was TurboTax: I said I would switch to Tax Cut (I didn’t say I would drop Quicken, because the truth is I probably wouldn’t).

That was last night. This morning I got a phone call from a very concerned marketing VP at Intuit. That’s the company that doesn’t do tech support and never answers my email about bugs in Quicken. She just saw my email and she want me to know that Intuit is very concerned about my opinion, that this is the first she’s heard of this and of course they are concerned. She’s put in a call to the marketing people, but of course Intuit has no control over what shows its ads run on.

I suggested to her that in fact networks make accommodations all the time if a sponsor doesn’t want to be on a show, and if her people were telling her different, maybe she should ask some questions.

Meanwhile, I’m thinking there were over 100,000 visits to the Open Letter site before I got there. I can’t really be the first person to actually write to Intuit, can I? (Although I used the web comment form as well as email, so who knows?). But never mind. I take her to mediamatters.org and to the An Open Letter to Chris Matthews site, and she professes amazement. I say that while Matthews has a First Amendment right to say what he likes, I am a Democrat, and I find it very offensive to have Democrats compared to terrorists. And if Intuit is paying for that with their ads, I think they are responsible for it and they’re associated with it, and I don’t want their product any more.

And so Ms. VP says she’ll call me back if the ad policy changes. I say I’d love it if they change the ad policy,and I look forward to hearing from her soon, and we part best of friends. Or something. And I’m not holding my breath, but who knows.

This entry was posted in The Media. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to What He Said, What I Did, What They Said

  1. “Meanwhile, I’m thinking there were over 100,000 visits to the Open Letter site before I got there. I can’t really be the first person to actually write to Intuit, can I?”

    Yes.

    This is the reason for a certain failure of the Internet for activism. Talk is cheap. Very cheap.

  2. Joe says:

    I’m surprised that you still use Quicken and Turbotax. They are both notorious internet whores that have probably divulged all of your significant financial data to the Quicken servers. And, Chris Matthews has been a worthless punk for some time.

  3. p.lukasiak says:

    Sorry seth, but lots of people have written to Intuit….

    And although our host isn’t Duncan Black, he does have a “select” influential audience (heck, you’re here, right? :) ).

    …..and he’s got that famous last name. So I can believe that the people at Intuit would want to get back to him personally…..

    (in fact, the people at Intuit have to be shitting themselves right now…. they have all these boxes of TurboTax 2006 sitting on the shelves, next to TaxCut and other tax filing software, and a boycott right now could do major damage to them…..)

  4. global yokel says:

    If you need another issue to get pissed about, here’s a good one: The so-called “socially responsible” outfit Working Assets uses MBNA to process their credit card business. Now guess who is the single largest corporate donor to the Bushniks?

    You got it — MBNA. I called WA and complained, and got the usual polite but ineffectual response.

  5. janinsanfran says:

    Can they have possibly mistaken you for another Froomkin?

  6. Ah, that must be it – “Froomkin’s writing in about Matthews!”, I can see how that would strike fear into the heart of a marketing VP. Concur, they confused you with another Froomkin (just like p.lukasiak must have me confused with someone else, maybe the Seth who works for EFF …).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.