Monthly Archives: October 2003

Whitehouse.gov Seeks to Put Iraq Statements Down the Memory Hole

I had a small cascade of reactions to this (via Eschaton).

First thought: It's disgusting that the White House is trying to relegate its statements about Iraq to the Memory Hole.

Second thought: It's great to live in a free country where this doesn't work.

Third thought: This demonstrates the same level of technical (in)competence we see in so many things this Administration does.

Fourth thought: Maybe it does work more often than not — many people have come to rely on Google. Efforts like this often won't get spotted most of the time.

Fifith set of thoughts: How do we prevent, or at least identify and publicize and warn about, this sort of activity in the future? Will this mean that commercial databases which keep pristine copies of things and promise not to santize still have a place? Can something like archive.org overcome this sort of attack on our online history? Is there anything Congress could or should do about this? (Needen't ask “would”—we know the answer to that.)

Update: Sixth thought: Well, they just made it much less accessible (although people who rely on google might get the idea the statements didn't exist), as far as we know they didn't actually delete them. It could be worse. But it's also more deniable.

Seventh thought: If I ran Google, would I now instruct my spiders to ignore the robots.txt file at whitehouse.gov?

Posted in Internet | 4 Comments

Linking as Civil Disobedience

Lawmeme asks How Direct is Too Direct When It Comes to Hyperlinks?

Let's see. Can't host the files. Can't link to the files. Can't link to a site with the files. Where will the madness end? This is the Internet. Hyperlinking doesn't supply easy dividing lines, and when you start telling people what they can and can't link, you start murderizing the Web.

Then they give links to

  • a site with the memos
  • a site that links to a site with the memos.
  • a site that links to a site that links to a site with the memos.
  • a site that links to a site that links to a site that links to a site with the memos.

Then, there's the kicker:

Here's a link to a site that links to a site that links to a site that links to a site that links to a site with the memos. Whoops, that's the Diebold home page.

My own personal view is that a hyperlink is and should be every bit as illegal as a footnote in an academic article.

Posted in Law: Copyright and DMCA | Comments Off on Linking as Civil Disobedience

What Does The FT’s Computer Know That We Don’t?

So, Clickable ThumbnailI'm reading the Financial Times's account of how the CIA is telling the Senate that Naming of agent 'was aimed at discrediting CIA' and idly wondering if it's a bad thing or a terrible thing when a banana republic's Great Power's clandestine services get into a war with the Junta Chief Executive, when I notice that the FT's computer has a couple of stories that it has identifed as related to the Bush administration's unprecedented betrayal of a clandestine CIA operative.

Click the thumbnail to see the apt headlines to the two links

Posted in Completely Different | Comments Off on What Does The FT’s Computer Know That We Don’t?

A Very Loud Noise All Around

All of a sudden there's this very loud noise all around. People in neighboring homes, shouting, cheering?, jeering?, it's 11pm at night, this is not usual behavior in my usually quiet neighborhood.

Then I flip to ESPN.com and I understand: the Marlins have won the Series.

(I guess that means the owners will be coming back to the taxpayers again, to demand we pay for their stadium.)

Posted in Miami | Comments Off on A Very Loud Noise All Around

An Unbelievably Bad Idea

Here's a trial balloon that deserves not only to be shot down, but shredded, dispersed, and probably exorcized:Pentagon wants 'mini-nukes' to fight terrorists. Imagine what happens when other nations build these and then they fall into the wrong hands. (Due to the nature of their likely uses, tactical weapons tend to be more dispersed and less well guarded than strategic ones.)

And, oh yes, might there be a moral issue about a national policy of envisioning and thus encouraging (in the sense of failing to maintain our stand against) the casual use of nukes? Or maybe a strategic cost to those of us living in a target-rich environment about undermining the international norm against the use of nuclear weaponry? Hello?

Posted in Politics: US | Comments Off on An Unbelievably Bad Idea

9/11 Commission Readies Subpoenas

Administration Faces Supoenas From 9/11 Panel.

Key quotes from Co-Chair Max Cleland,

“It's obvious that the White House wants to run out the clock here,” he said in an interview in Washington. “It's Halloween, and we're still in negotiations with some assistant White House counsel about getting these documents — it's disgusting.”

“As each day goes by, we learn that this government knew a whole lot more about these terrorists before Sept. 11 than it has ever admitted.”

Posted in Politics: US | Comments Off on 9/11 Commission Readies Subpoenas